The Association of Occupational Health and Wellbeing Professionals​

Supporting you through your Occupational Health career

Over 1500 Members
Registered Charity No. 1205635

Why It’s Time to Transition from Pure Tone Audiometry to OAE

By Peter Wilson

Published 1 November 2026

Home / iOH Blog / Why It’s Time to Transition from Pure Tone Audiometry to OAE
Otoacoustic Emission (OAE) audiometry

If you are an occupational health professional, a legal and hearing health storm has broken. In the landmark UK court case of Barry v Ministry of Defence, the judge awarded a startling £713,716 for a single occupational hearing damage case. The judgment included damages for synaptic damage, not just traditional audiometry results, and accounted for future disability and life opportunities.

Traditionally, hearing conservation programme health surveillance has been based on Pure Tone Audiometry (PTA). But PTA is largely a placebo checkbox exercise, not a risk management tool. It merely catalogues failures long after permanent damage has occurred.

There is a “no brainer” change required to protect the health of the workforce and to shield organisations from the tidal wave of costly civil litigation and soaring insurance premiums. It is time to transition to a proactive risk management tool: Otoacoustic Emission (OAE) audiometry.

A Lagging Placebo: PTA failures

The cochlea has a row of inner hair cells and three rows of outer hair cells (OHCs). When exposed to noise, the outer hair cells are damaged first. PTA only measures the subjective response to simple pure tones which is little affected by initial damage to the OHCs. Consequently, up to 50% of OHCs can be destroyed before any hearing loss is measurable using PTA.

As a result, if audiograms are “normal” it is assumed that PPE is working and employees are not at risk, despite cochlear damage e.g. tinnitus and communication difficulties etc. PTA is a lagging indicator that simply catalogues a failure to protect staff.

Quoting the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), conventional audiometry is “a tax on the failure to control risk”. It does not prevent hearing damage; it merely records some of the damage many years after the event.

Enter OAE: a proactive, leading indicator

OAE audiometry changes the paradigm from injury measurement long after the damage has been done to injury prevention.

OAE objectively measures the biomechanical response of the outer hair cells to assess their health. When a sound pulse is transmitted into the ear, healthy hair cells are not passive, they “twitch” when stimulated. That movement generates a tiny return pulse detected by OAE equipment to assess hair cell health. This provides a direct, objective and very sensitive measurement of the condition of the cochlea that has been used to assess the hearing of babies since the 1970s. What has changed is the sophistication of the software.

For occupational health teams, the practical benefits of OAE are game-changing:

  • Objective test: unlike PTA, OAE does not rely on a subjective response. The subject is passive so there are no language/nerves/hangover etc issues
  • Fast and simple: OAE tests take two minutes and don’t require a costly soundproof booth, a quiet office is fine
  • Simple to understand and motivational: “Last year your OHC damage was 12%, now it is 18%, we need to do something” provides immediate, data-driven motivation to reduce risk

The Risks of Remaining Deaf to the Benefits of OAE

Health

Recent research has shown that the health and socioeconomic damage associated with Noise Induced Hearing Loss (NIHL) is far, far worse than previously assumed. For example, NIHL is the dominant modifiable risk associated with the likelihood of experiencing dementia

Wealth

The financial consequences of continuing with legacy PTA are serious. The new legal framework changes how courts evaluate claims. The recently proven more severe, long-term health risks of NIHL can be considered, so much higher awards (c.f. the recent >£700k) could be the new norm, not to mention the knock-on effects on insurance premiums.

The first line of defence: PPE: not as effective as assumed…

PPE is the default, and often the only, risk reduction measure implemented. Sadly, PPE typically provides only a tiny fraction of the protection assumed. If the supplier claims 20dB to 30dB attenuation, the real-world attenuation is much more likely to be only 3dB – 10dB. Thus, for noise levels much above 90dB(A), it is extremely difficult to guarantee adequate protection. PTA tells you this too late and therefore simply provides ammunition for potential six-figure claims.

Making the transition: a practical process

PTA will remain as it is a regulatory staple. OH professionals should, however, implement a hybrid approach to reduce the risk to employee health and company wealth.

Baselines: use both PTA and OAE for initial health surveillance (new employees)

Annual OAE: annual OAE tests are fast and low cost and provide early indications of risk management failings to trigger an urgent review of workplace risk management elements

PTA on damage detection: if an annual OAE test reveals significant damage, trigger regulatory PTA testing

Triennial PTA: use PTA triennially to satisfy regulatory requirements

OAE adoption turns health surveillance from a passive “injury cataloguing” exercise into a proactive risk reduction measure. As such it is just one element in the urgent revision of NIHL risk reduction measures necessary to protect employee health and to reduce the financial risks to the organisation. These changes include a re-evaluation of PPE performance, noise reporting and modern noise control to determine your NIHL risk reduction Return on Investment (ROI). These changes are the subject of a forthcoming article on how to achieve Nil NIHL.

Online resources found here

invc.com

AI statement

No AI tools were used for this article other than to generate pictures

Peter Wilson Headshot

Peter Wilson | Linkedin

Peter is the Technical Director at the Industrial Noise and Vibration Centre with over 40 years’ experience. A popular speaker at conferences worldwide due both to expertise and perhaps being unusually entertaining (possibly a spin-off from doing stand-up comedy as a hobby…). He wrote the IOSH competency courses in both noise and hand-arm vibration. He also has a reputation for developing innovative engineering noise and vibration control techniques, including award-winning aerodynamic fan noise control technology and acoustic barriers, remote analysis technology, dynamic vibration absorbers and etc.

He has also been involved in mental health campaigns at conferences, in schools and in national TV advertisements.

Leave a Comment

Related articles to : ,
Scroll to Top