The Association of Occupational Health and Wellbeing Professionals​

Supporting you through your Occupational Health career

Over 1500 Members
Registered Charity No. 1205635

Competence in Occupational Health – an opinion piece

By Kira Milne

Published 21 October 2024

Home / iOH Blog / Competence in Occupational Health – an opinion piece

What makes an Occupational Health (OH) Professional or Occupational Health service be seen as competent? There has been significant debate on this topic. Given the variety of educational approaches, training, and the multidisciplinary nature of OH, it is not always clear how this translates into professional competent practice. The purpose of this article is to clarify competence in OH practice, taking account of current professional standards and focusing on health and safety statutory regulation.

The National Institute of Health (NIH) (2024) states “competencies are the knowledge, skills, abilities, and behaviours that contribute to individual and organisational performance. Registered healthcare professionals are required to be cognisant of professional registration standards, which must be upheld.

The Nursing and Midwifery Code (NMC 2018) standard thirteen is to “preserve safety” which is to “recognise and work within the limits of your competence”.

The Health Care and Professionals Council (HCPC) 2016 Standards, standard three is to “work within the limits of your knowledge and skills”.

The General Medical Council (GMC) (2024) stipulates “providing a good standard of practice and care and working within competence”.

All these standards identify the requirements for professional and safe practice which is core to any professional registrant working in any healthcare setting. However, the provision of OH services is more than just adhering to professional standards; it is understanding and demonstrating competent practice relating to legislative and ethical requirements and providing safe, effective and high-quality care.

According to the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), in 2023, 1.8 million workers were suffering from work-related ill health. 35.2 million working days were lost to work-related ill health and non-fatal injury, including 12,000 cases of lung disease due to exposures, with costs to the economy of £20.7 billion.  Employers that use OH services especially Small and Medium Enterprises (SME) rely on OH professionals to have the necessary competence to support their organisation to meet legislative requirements. This is especially true with the management of health risks and health surveillance aiming to prevent, monitor and manage work-related ill health. 

The HSE are the UK national regulators for workplace health and safety and provide guidance to aid employers with legislative requirements. Regulation 7(1) of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations (MHSWR) 1999 requires employers to appoint one or more competent persons to assist them in undertaking the measures needed to comply with health and safety requirements. The competent person must have sufficient training, experience or knowledge and other qualities to properly assist the employer comply with their legal duties (HSE 2024a).   

Therefore, OH professionals should be able to assist employers in taking the measures needed to comply with the requirements and prohibitions imposed upon them by the statutory provision. Demonstrating understanding of what the relevant statutory provisions require, in addition to the arrangements needed to ensure adequate co-operation between the employer and occupational health provision/service. 

The HSE, do not regulate healthcare registration (this is the role of statutory regulatory bodies such as the Nursing Midwifery Council (NMC), General Medical Council (GMC) and Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC)) nor do they regulate, accredit, develop, or deliver any OH education.  Standards for education sit with the professional registration bodies that set and review standards for education, training, conduct, and performance leading to and maintaining healthcare registration.

To demonstrate competence the HSE expect registered practitioners to act with professionalism and integrity and work within agreed professional, ethical and legal frameworks, whilst demonstrating the necessary knowledge, skills, experience and attributes.  This is inclusive of ongoing continual professional development to ensure the delivery of contemporary evidence-based practice as part of their registration. 

Within the UK there are a variety of educational options specific to OH such as diplomas, degrees, graduate certificates/diplomas and master’s degrees (MScs) with some MScs for nurses being validated by the NMC.  The HSE recognises that the NMC has set standards for the OH qualification (SCPHN OH for nurses) which requires the demonstration of achievement of standards leading to registration on the NMC register, however, this is not the only route to competence for OH professionals.  There has been recent debate related to OH qualifications and competence, with the suggestion that the HSE prefer one nursing OH qualification over another. This is not reflected in HSE’s guidance on competence (HSE 2024b). 

The HSE focus is on compliance with health and safety legislation for all employers, and the competence of OH professionals assisting employers to comply with their statutory duties. Under Section 3 of the Health and Safety at Work etc., Act 1974 an OH Service must conduct their undertaking in such a way as to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that persons not in their employment (service users) who may be affected by the occupational health services actions or non-action are not exposed to risks to their health or safety (HSE 2024a).

For example, – if an OH service or professional has been contracted by an employer (the primary duty holder), as a competent person under the MHSWR 1999 to deliver statutory health surveillance, the OH service is required to provide adequate advice and information to the primary duty holder to help them manage their health risks. Suppose the OHS fails to identify or act on positive findings or carry out health surveillance in line with the specific legislative requirements. In that case, the OHS may be exposing the primary duty holders (employer) employees to risks to their health and safety. Therefore, can be held accountable under Section 3 and Section 36 of the HSWA 1974.  

The HSE (and the local authorities in the case of shops, hotels etc) have powers to prosecute under criminal law but do not have responsibility for applying the civil law (HSE 2024i). Where an injured employee seeks compensation from the employer, they must pursue an action for damages in tort (delict in Scotland) in the civil courts. This is common law, not statutory, liability. Although it is not permitted to insure against potential criminal liability, because that is contrary to public policy, employers have a duty under the Employers’ Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969 to insure against civil liability to their employees. An employer is vicariously liable in civil law for the negligence of an employee committed in the course of their employment, but vicarious liability does not apply in criminal law. In one case a directly employed OH physician was found to be negligent in not warning the employer about a carcinogenic substance that caused the death of an employee exposed to that substance in the workplace and the employer was held vicariously liable to compensate the widow of that employee in the civil law (Stokes v GKN, Kloss 2020).

As regards the criminal liability of employees (rather than the employer) section 7 HSWA 1974 provides that an employee has a duty to take reasonable care for the health and safety of himself and of other persons who may be affected by his acts or omissions at work and to co-operate with his employer so far as is necessary to enable the employer to comply with his statutory duties. A directly employed OH professional could be prosecuted under this section. As regards an independent OH professional or service they could potentially be prosecuted under section 36 HSWA 1974 which provides that “where the commission by any person of an offence is due to the act or default of some other person, that other person shall be guilty of the offence”. Kloss (2020) provides the example of an external occupational hygienist who was convicted under section 36 HSWA 1974 when their incompetent advice led to an employer exposing its employees to excessive levels of hazardous dust. For that reason, the OH professional and service should be aware of the HSWA 1974 and their responsibilities under the health and safety regulations, but also of their potential liability for negligence in the civil law, remembering that employers and sole practitioners should be insured against civil liability (Kloss 2020).

The HSE outline competence from a health and safety perspective. They stipulate competence should be a key part of workplace activities, and not an add-on or afterthought. They define competence “as the combination of training, skills, experience and knowledge that a person has and their ability to apply them to perform a task safely” (HSE 2024c).

Competence and Health Surveillance

One of the core remits of OH service is the delivery of health surveillance for employers. This is underpinned by legislation and risk assessment depends on exposures to certain hazards such as noise, vibration, and substances hazardous to health. Combined with factors such as where there have been previous cases of work-related ill health in the workforce/place; where there is reliance on PPE; the wearing of respirators to prevent asthma, and/or where there is evidence of ill health in jobs within the industry. Each specific regulation identifies the employer’s responsibility for the requirement of the provision of health surveillance (HSE 2024c, HSE 2024d).

Some regulations stipulate the requirement to appoint an HSE-approved doctor (asbestos, lead, compressed air, ionising radiation, and exposure to certain substances (see below), and require the exposed personnel to be assessed by medical surveillance. For example, The Control of Lead at Work Regulations 2002 (Regulation 10 (1).

  • Every employer shall ensure that each of his employees who is or is liable to be exposed to lead is under suitable medical surveillance by a relevant doctor.

HSE will assess the management arrangement between the employer and occupation health service which provides health surveillance e.g.:

  • Where health surveillance is required, was it set up and delivered with input from a competent occupational health professional, for example, an occupational health doctor or nurse?
  • Did the employer consider if you are buying occupational health support for health surveillance only or were other occupational health activities, for example, safety-critical medicals or managing sick leave included?
  • Does the employer understand the services they require? Did this information help them choose an occupational health professional with the right skills and competence?
  • Did the employer assess the occupational health professionals’ competence to provide the services that they needed, including occupational health experience relevant to the industry and workplace?
  • Did the occupational health professional observe the work activities? Does the employer understand that it is vital that the occupational health service understand their health hazards and risks?
  • Is there evidence of the explicit roles and responsibilities of doctors, OH nurses, and OH technicians i.e. who interprets HS results and when.

(HSE 2024c, HSE 2024d)

Competence, Health Surveillance and Occupational Health Qualifications

The HSE (2024b) stipulate that an assessment of competence is outlined by professional qualifications, a demonstration of continued professional development and clinical governance. For example, concerning health surveillance their web pages state:

Doctors should be registered with the General Medical Council and should hold an occupational medicine qualification, for example:

  • Diploma in Occupational Medicine (DOccMed), usually a general practitioner, has a basic level of competence across the field of occupational medicine and understands the practical and ethical considerations that apply at work.
  • Associates of the Faculty of Occupational Medicine hold a higher qualification (AFOM) and are usually in training to become specialists.
  • Members of the Faculty (MFOM) are specialists who should be able to deal with the full range and complexity of workplace health problems.

Nurses should as a minimum be registered with the NMC they may also hold an OH qualification,

  • Certificate, diploma, or degree, which may be recorded on Part 3 of the NMC register Specialist Community Public Health Nursing (SCPHN)

Occupational health technician (support worker) – A non-medical or nursing professional

  • There is no governing body or HSE-recognised qualification for occupational health technicians.
  • If technicians engage in health surveillance, they should receive training from a competent training provider for the specific aspects of work they participate in, for example, spirometry and audiometry.
  • An occupational health physician or nurse must supervise their work.
  • They must not work outside their competencies and must not interpret test results or provide feedback from health surveillance.

Responsible person – conduct simple screening as part of your health surveillance scheme.

  • A responsible person is someone an employer appoints who is competent to conduct simple screening and report any positive findings to an occupational health professional. An employer can appoint someone from their workforce to be a responsible person.
  • They should:
  • be trained to deliver the aspects of work they participate in, such as simple screening. The training can be delivered by an occupational health professional or via a formal training course.
  • have a clearly defined role.
  • be someone trusted by the workforce.
  • have good communication and interpersonal skills.
  • create and send records to be stored as part of the health surveillance system.
  • not make any judgements if symptoms are disclosed to them.

(HSE 2024b)

Plan Do Check Act

The HSE (2024f) measures performance as part of the Plan, Do, Check, Act with health and safety and health surveillance and key principles should be demonstrated under this 4-step process:

  • Is the statutory health surveillance (HS) performed compliant with the requirement of the specific health and safety regulations (e.g. COSHH, Control of Asbestos Regulations, Control of Vibration at Work Regulations, Control of Noise at Work Regulations), benchmarked against standards e.g., ACoP, Guidance.
  • Are the findings documented on the medical record and the outcomes shared with recommendations via the health record (HSE 2024g) with the employer?
  • Is feedback given to employers to check control measures are working effectively.
  • Is advice provided on the accuracy of relevant risk assessments and the effectiveness of control measures?
  • Is advice provided where added steps are needed to manage risks when they are identified?
  • Are OH professionals learning from incidents, ill-health data, errors, and relevant experience, including from other organisations and grouped anonymous data.
  • Revisiting plans, policy documents and risk assessments to see if they need updating.
  • Is action being taken on lessons learned, including from audit and review of reports.

Therefore, any OH professional or service running a statutory health surveillance scheme needs to ensure robust processes to support employers to comply with health and safety legislation.

Competence and Occupational Health Practice

How can OH professionals demonstrate competence in practice? As registrants’ competence is embedded in core professional standards to ensure the delivery of safe, effective, high quality and evidence-based practice.  In addition to professional standards, there is the requirement to ensure a good understanding and compliance with the statutory regulations that underpin all OH practices. This can be demonstrated through appropriate qualifications, training, continuing professional development, accreditation, and robust quality management processes.

  1. Qualifications

Being able to demonstrate a professional registration is the first step however, if part of the OH professional remit is to oversee any legislative requirements such as health surveillance for employers, then a relevant occupational health qualification is essential unless you are a trainee or technician and being supervised appropriately by an occupational health qualified registered professional.

 As there are a variety of occupational health course options available, this qualification could be demonstrated with a suitable occupational health diploma, degree, MSc or other regulatory body approved OH Education  

  1. Quality Management and Accreditation

Ensuring robust quality management processes are in place can demonstrate to external bodies such as the HSE competence of staff and delivery of OH practice in relation to legislation. Regular audit and review of all OH services, policy documents and reporting arrangements, benchmarked against legislative requirements, application of ACoPs and guidance, supports the demonstration of competence.  This also ensures services are being delivered in line with service level agreements and key performance indicators which support the provision of feedback for employer and employees, such as recommendations on a review of risk assessments and controls, fitness status of employees and where relevant RIDDOR reporting (HSE 2024g, HSE 2024h). Therefore, the OH service can demonstrate not just the provision of health surveillance services, but advice to the employer, as appropriate, acting on the results.

Quality management processes can be demonstrated through accreditation schemes such as ISO 7101, ISO 451001, ISO 9001 and the OH-focused SEQOHS.

  1. Continuing Professional Development and Revalidation

In addition to registration and occupational health qualification, you must be able to demonstrate ongoing training i.e. continuing professional development. Regarding health surveillance, appropriate courses and education on risk assessment, health hazards and the health surveillance assessment processes are a recommended starting point e.g., audiometry, spirometry, skin assessment, and HAVS assessment (with an understanding of the different HAVS Tiers and who is considered competent for what tier) and when medical surveillance is required. The HSE will check specific competency requirements and review evidence of this, for example, certificates of competency for hand-arm vibration syndrome assessments, spirometry, or audiometry.

This ongoing continuation of development feeds into maintaining professional standards and relevant registration.

Conclusions

This article has endeavoured to provide insight into the current debate surrounding OH competence, focusing on the alignment of OH practices with legislation rather than recommending specific educational pathways.

At present, various options for OH education is available, and healthcare professionals specialising in OH must critically evaluate these options to determine which best suits their individual needs and learning objectives. While the HSE may align itself with NMC-approved OH qualifications it is essential to note that these standards are not codified in legislation and are not inherently superior to other OH education provisions. Instead, they are simply one of several available quality-assured options.

Informed opinions on OH education should be grounded in a clear understanding of the relevant legislation, content and quality assurance of the course, as failure to follow these requirements can have serious consequences for the health and well-being of the UK workforce. Moreover, the lack of clarity on OH competence can hinder the recruitment of new registrants across all disciplines, thereby affecting the overall capacity of the OH profession.

When undertaking statutory health and safety functions, the competent OH Professional should be able to demonstrate that they are meeting the requirements set out in the health and safety legislation, ACoP and HSE guidance, that they have a suitable OH qualification and are acting within their sphere of competence.   

Kira Milne HeadshotAuthor :

Kira Milne, RGN, SCPHN OH, FHEA, NMC Teacher, DipHe Nursing, BN Nursing, BA Occupational Health, PG Cert LTA, MSc Public Health 

Editors :

Diana Kloss MBE; Faculty of Occupational Health Nurses (FOHN), National School of Occupational Health (NSOH); Lynda Bruce (iOH) and Billy Jackson (RGU)

References

General Medical Council. (2024). Good medical practice. Available at: GMC Good Medical Practice (Accessed: 11/07/2024).

Health & Care Professions Council. (2024). Standards of conduct, performance and ethics. Available at: HCPC Standards. (Accessed: 11/07/2024)

Health and Safety Executive. (2023). Health and Safety statistics: 2022 to 2023 annual release. Available at: HSE Statistics (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024a). Health and Safety at Work: Criminal and civil law. Available at: Criminal law in regard to Health and safety at work – HSE (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024b). Occupational health – Assess the competence of occupational health professionals. Available at: Occupational health – Assess the competence of occupational health professionals (hse.gov.uk) (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024c). What is Competence? Available at: What is Competence? – Competence in health and safety (hse.gov.uk)  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024d). Health Surveillance – Understand your business needs. Available at: Health surveillance – Understand what type your business needs (hse.gov.uk) (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024e). Health Surveillance and Occupational Health Available at: Health surveillance and occupational health – HSE  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024f). Introduction to managing health and safety: How to manage health and safety. Available at: Introduction to managing health and safety: How to manage health and safety – HSE   (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024g). Health Surveillance. Record keeping. Available at: Health surveillance – Record keeping (hse.gov.uk)  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024h). RIDDOR – Reporting of Injuries, Disease and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations. Available at: RIDDOR – Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations 2013 – HSE  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Health and Safety Executive. (2024i). Health and Safety at Work: Criminal and Civil Law. Available at: Health and safety at work: criminal and civil law – HSE  (Accessed: 11 July 2024)

International Organisation for Standardisation (ISO). (2018). ISO 45001 Healthcare organisation management. Available at:  ISO 45001:2018 – Occupational health and safety management systems — Requirements with guidance for use  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

International Organisation for Standardisation (ISO). (2021). ISO 9001 Quality Management systems. Available at:  ISO 9001:2015 – Quality management systems  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

International Organisation for Standardisation (ISO). (2023). ISO 7101 Healthcare organisation management. ISO 7101:2023 – Healthcare organization management — Management systems for quality in healthcare organizations — Requirements (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

National Institutes of Health (NIH). (2024). What are Competencies. Available at: What are competencies? | Office of Human Resources (nih.gov)  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

Kloss, D. (2020) Occupational Health Law. 6th ed. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley and Sons.

Kloss, D. (2008) Vicarious liability. Its application to safety and health at work, Occupational Health at Work, 4(5), pp. 31 -32.

Kloss, D. (2012) Criminal Law. Criminal liability under health and safety law, Occupational Health at Work, 9(3), pp. 35 -36.

Kloss, D. (2024) Health, safety and disability. An employer’s duty under the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974. Occupational Health at Work, 21(3), pp. 36 – 40

Nursing & Midwifery Council. (2018). The code: Professional standards of practice and behaviour for nurses, midwives, and nursing associates. Available at: NMC Code (Accessed: 11/07/2024).

Nursing and Midwifery Council. (2023). Standards of proficiencies for specialist community public health nurses (SCPHN). Available at:   Standards of proficiency for specialist community public health nurses (SCPHN) – The Nursing and Midwifery Council (nmc.org.uk)  (Accessed: 11 July 2024). 

Safe Effective Quality Occupational Health Service (SEQOHS). (2024). The industry Standards for occupational health services.  Available at: SEQOHS  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

The Control of Lead at Work Regulations 2022, No. 2676.   The Control of Lead at Work Regulations 2002 (legislation.gov.uk)  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

The Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974, c. 37.  Available at:  Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 (legislation.gov.uk)  (Accessed:11 July 2024).

The Management of Health and Safety At Work Regulations 1999, No. 3242, Available at:   The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 (legislation.gov.uk)  (Accessed: 11 July 2024).

1 thought on “Competence in Occupational Health – an opinion piece”

  1. Kira outlines several key recommendations for improving competence in occupational health (OH). They compare favourably with global practices and findings from Delphi studies:
    Enhanced Training emphasises the need for comprehensive training programs tailored to the evolving needs of OH professionals.
    The development of Standardised Competency Frameworks advocates for the development and implementation of standardised approach to ensure quality and consistency in OH practice.
    Continuous Professional Development (CPD) stresses the importance of ongoing education and training to keep OH professionals updated with the latest practices and knowledge.
    Interdisciplinary Collaboration encourages collaboration between different health disciplines to provide holistic health protection.
    Use of Technology recommends leveraging technology to improve efficiency and effectiveness in OH services.

Leave a Comment

Related articles to : ,
Scroll to Top